DC Cookie

Tuesday, April 11, 2006

My Pal Juan

Despite being an immigrant myself [albeit, unfairly privileged, but legal], I have not been following this immigration bill. I can't vote in either my homeland or my country of residence; hence, politics bore me. But that's no excuse for ignorance. Over the weekend, my boyfriend wrote a relatively passionate bulletin about his views on the issue, so I thought it my duty to find out more. After my early evening gym class, I wandered down to an incredibly crowded, but peaceful demonstration on the Mall. A gym acquaintance's husband was manning the acoustics, so I stood in the sound booth near the stage and listened to eloquent and fiery spanish over the loudspeaker. I understood about 5% of the words, but about 95% of the message. It was moving, to say the least.

Which, inadvertently, got me thinking about my buddies in my office building. There are three people I see almost every day, who coincidentally make my day every time they say hello. The first is the man who works on B4 of the parking garage, washes and details my automotive beast for a bargain-basement (no pun intended) price, and saves me a prime parking space when I'm late (which is often). His accent is heavy, his words are few, but his kindness is overwhelming. He recently told me that his company might be transferring him. It nearly broke my heart.

The second is the woman who enters my office around 8pm each evening to empty my basura and recycling. She always asks politely if she can come in while I'm working. I always thank her, because her work is thankless, but she attacks it with pride and contentment.

The third is my pal Juan*. He is in charge of the appearance of the building's main entrances and hallways. When I leave in the evening, he is buffing the floors. His eyes light up when I turn the corner. He waves as I walk towards him (and the parking elevator). He says hello with a gusto that melts away my stress. He stops his work for the few moments of our verbal exchange, and his face beams as I say, "Hi! How are you?" and he replies "Yes!" As the doors close on the elevator, Juan has invariably made me giggle and blush.

"Si, se puede."

*Juan is the name I have given him...one day I will ask his real name.

20 Comments:

  • At April 11, 2006 4:24 PM, Blogger Jeff Simmermon said…

    Hey Miss Cookie -- I did a little thing about this issue my damn self. Have a look.

     
  • At April 11, 2006 5:11 PM, Blogger VP of Dior said…

    it really is a tough issue. on one hand i think the u.s. should curb illegal immigrants from ALL countries because of increasing threats of terrorism and declining services for the poor and unemployed. but on the other hand when you ask people who will step up and do certain jobs that many immigrants do for little pay, all of a sudden they are at a loss for words. i think there is no easy answer.

     
  • At April 11, 2006 5:30 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    I think that the great majority of Americans recognize that our country was built by immigrants and will continue to need immigration in the future. It's the illegal part that needs to be controlled.

    Ms. Cookie is a prime example - her family played by the rules and jumped through all the hoops required for US residency; she has to check in periodically with the INS, etc. Is it fair that other immigrants are just walking in?

    If you're coming to enjoy the benefits of living in the US, is it too much to as for you to:
    1. Wait in line for your turn, and
    2. Let us know who you are, where you are going, and what you are doing, for everyone's protection.

    The really alarming thing about this is our elected government's complete inability to take even the slightest action on this issue before skipping town for Easter. Controlling the border is the most basic duty of any government...

     
  • At April 11, 2006 5:43 PM, Blogger DC Cookie said…

    Although I'm not prepared with enough information to debate anyone's opinions on this subject, I would interject that, had any privileged Americans, or Canadians for that matter, ever experienced life outside of our rich and leisurely bubble, we might not be so hard on those illegal immigrants who are here for the sole purpose of creating a better life for their families.

    My greencard was virtually handed to me by a rich corporation. I'm not sure a migrant farmer from Mexico would ever be given the same chance that I was given, even if he were to offer to wait in line...for years.

    Do we have any stats on how many terrorists were actually illegal immigrants, or here in the country legally, because they had the money to jump the line (or came in through Canada)?

    I personally, don't EVER want to have to pick grapes 18 hours a day, 7 days a week, so that my punk-ass can drink fine wine.

     
  • At April 11, 2006 6:07 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Illegal aliens are criminals (let's call a spade a spade) and should be treated as such. They are different than legal, law-abiding immigrants who have followed the proper policies and procedures in order to be here. Unfortunately people in the media and the left-wing political realm rarely make a distinction between the two (legal vs. illegal.) It makes me so fired up! Not only do we need more secure borders but another important issue that needs to be addressed is how quickly we can round up the criminals and send them home instead of continuing to reward them with social services, healthcare, education, day laborer sites, etc.

     
  • At April 11, 2006 6:17 PM, Blogger DC Cookie said…

    Yeah - we particularly need to police that damn Canadian border...

     
  • At April 11, 2006 9:16 PM, Blogger Tyler said…

    Great post Cookie.

     
  • At April 11, 2006 10:40 PM, Blogger Barbara said…

    One of my very best friends at work is Morena, a legal immigrant from El Salvador. She empties my basura around 4 PM every day and brings me wonderful home-cooked tamales. She even taught me how to make tamales, which tasted a lot better before I realized how much lard goes into them. These people are doing all the menial jobs in this country right now. Without them, I can't imagine how all this work would get done.

     
  • At April 12, 2006 1:54 AM, Blogger Drunken Chud said…

    i don't care to criminalize this, however, i do feel that they need to go through the citizenship process properly. and definately pay a fine for breaking the law. but really, the only way to force that to happen is to do an SS style crackdown on employers of illegal aliens. televise it, and villify them. when the country sees mom and pop kettle getting dragged out of their farmhouse, or seeing mcdonalds or wal-mart ceo's being dragged out in shackles and threatened with prosecution under the patriot act, we can then force the hand of other companies and farms and whatnot to stop using the labor till they sign up for guest worker status and citizenship. (which would need to be put in place obviously). we don't even have to actually prosecute the people we dragged out. just the show of force and the threat is enough. simply let them on their merry way a little later after the press loses interest. the aliens themselves are not the problem. our economy can absorb them. it's the tax on the healthcare system and educational systems when 15 million people aren't paying proper taxes but still using the systems. sorry, i'm rambling. but to sum up, we don't need to be harder on the aliens, we need to be harder on the employers. which in turn forces the hand of the aliens. otherwise, there's no viable way to address this.

     
  • At April 12, 2006 9:36 AM, Blogger *** said…

    I've never commented before, but I do regularly read your blog. I just wanted to thank you for your entry, but also to make sure everyone understands that it is not possible for the majority of the people who are coming here illegally to enter legally. They can't get work sponsored visas because they have no education. They can't apply for the diversity lottery, because it doesn't apply to Mexico. They cross illegally because it's really their only option for coming here. Further, what do you tell someone who has been here illegally since they were two? And is now a productive, educated, employed and contributing 25 year-old who knows no other country?

    I don't like the idea that we use them as slaves, or that their economies have become dependent on money sent from this country, but the average migrant worker from Mexico doesn't have the same opportunities to immigrate here as inhabitants of nearly every other country. We take afghanis, iraqis even iranians...but, oh no, don't let the Mexicans in. Well, at least not legally, so that they have the same rights/responsibilities and freedoms as everyone else.

     
  • At April 12, 2006 11:31 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    It's not possible for me to own a Ferrari, but that doesn't mean I'm allowed to steal one.

    We need to set up a very fast, simple process for unskilled illegals to get registered. Ultimately, it will help protect them from exploitation, as well as helping os keep track of them.

     
  • At April 12, 2006 11:42 AM, Blogger Carrie Broadshoulders said…

    It's also VERY important to note that the issue here is NOT citizenship...it's a legal work status in this country. I am okay with setting up a process to allow illegal aliens to get work permits b/c they are in fact doing jobs no one else would do for that price or even at minimum wage, though I bet none are making that. I do NOT however think we give any special privileges to becoming a CITIZEN. Big difference. I also think if we choose to give a work status to these people, we also better be willing to curb the free entry into this country. It's amazing that we cannot keep poor migrants out of our borders but are waging a war a world away under the idea we're protecting ourselves. It's ABSURD.

    I don't particularly care about giving illegal aliens anything in particular since I think the only people who benefit from them being here are the large corporations who are basically using them as slave labor and not paying adequate wages. I was AMAZED that my own company supports making them legal workers, then realized why. Cheap labor. Trust me, there are plenty of people who are Americans who would pick tobacco or grapes or whatever else if the companies were forced to pay an adequate wage to get that labor. But if they can get the milk for nearly free, why pay for the cow?

    Anyone who believes in health care for all Americans, a social security system and all of the other socialist ideas that this country leans towards CANNOT want to allow these people free entry into our country. If so, then you're asking for the collapse of every social program that is already under great strain because we cannot afford to keep helping everyone if everyone keeps getting bigger and poorer. I battle with myself over whether the government has any duty to provide these social programs at all but at least recognize that if it is going to, we cannot let 11 million poor people join the ranks of those who would benefit from these programs. And continue to let more come across the border. If you want companies to have the cheap labor, let them pay for their healthcare and retirement plans.

     
  • At April 12, 2006 11:47 AM, Blogger *** said…

    Wiz, it IS possible for you to own a ferarri, if you work hard enough and make sacrifices. Someone who is born on a ranch in the middle of zacatecas, whose parents never sent them to school, who had to farm their land just to provide food for their brothers, sisters, grandparents, etc, has no choice.

    Very few people in this country truly understand poverty. Even our poorest usually have running water, electricity, and shoes on their feet.

    I am a believer that sometimes our laws are just wrong.

     
  • At April 12, 2006 12:33 PM, Blogger Carrie Broadshoulders said…

    There are other ways to solve the poverty of other nations than to allow them all safe harbor here in America. What Congress should be doing is to find ways to make migrants WANT to stay in Mexico. I have no issues with wanting to help others, but allowing illegal aliens to work here freely, we put a strain on our government's ability to help our own citizens while allowing corporations to get richer. That's fair to no one.

     
  • At April 12, 2006 4:17 PM, Blogger Mamma Bear said…

    I had a small confrontation with a young white man on the metro on Monday night. He was on the phone pretending to be important when he was saying that he was "late because of all of the MEXICANS." It was his tone that offended me and I let him know it.
    My best friend's father was an illegal in the 1970's coming from a country that was in the middle of a civil war. He came he for a better life for his family. He met a legal immigrant and they made an American family.
    As La Guera Loca said it is not easy for people to come over here legally...
    I thought the Statue of Liberty actually meant something...

    "Give me your tired, your poor,
    Your huddled masses yearning to
    breathe free,
    The wretched refuse of your teeming
    shore.
    Send these, the homeless, tempest-lost to me
    - Emma Lazarus, "The New Colossus," 1883"

     
  • At April 12, 2006 4:56 PM, Blogger Carrie Broadshoulders said…

    As you said, your friend's father escaped a civil war. We do make exceptions for people who are fleeing from persecution. Mexico is not in the middle of a civil war. It's just poor. And so is 80% of the rest of the world. Mexico just happens to be lucky enough to share a border with the United States. I'm not trying to be insensitive and all and I think the guy on the Metro should have been bitchslapped. I care about helping the poor. Absolutely. I'm a huge fan of the One Campaign. But frankly, opening our borders makes no sense and as I've said helps no one except big business and the lucky people who get here from Mexico. And at the wages they are earning here, I would not call them lucky in the long run. What would REALLY make sense and show that we are in fact very compassionate people, is to help end poverty abroad. In the style of Bush, who would rather fight than feed, we should help end poverty abroad than try to fix it here at home. And the tired argument that they do jobs Americans won't. Bullshit. They do jobs Americans would do if they were paid a salary that is respectable for a country of our wealth. It's economics. And the most logical solution is to make American less of a destination for illegal aliens by giving them a reason to stay home. If we had a truly free world market, Mexicans wouldn't need to come here to work.

    No one denies we are a country that should remain open, and we should be able to have people come here as workers. What concerns me is that we're not fixing anything along with giving illegal aliens here legal status. We're only legitimizing the problem by saying it's not a problem. That is the great travesty.

     
  • At April 12, 2006 11:19 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    QWP:
    "The next time some politician -- ANY politician -- prattles on about how illegal immigrants are an economic necessity, I want somebody to get in their face and force them to deal with the fact that what they're really saying is that our economic future is absolutely and unchangingly dependent on slavery.

    Because when you cut through all the BS, that's what's at the heart of it as far as I'm concerned. This rhetoric about "all the jobs Americans are unwilling to take" boils down to certain types of employers being allowed to get away with not paying a decent living wage (not to mention benefits) or provide decent working conditions because the people they're employing have no recourse to complain about how they're being treated.

    Call it what it is, people. Then maybe we can be honest about fixing it."

     
  • At April 13, 2006 11:47 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    As a black person, I understand exactly what the argument is. America has a long past of benefiting from immigrant labor. Basically people immigrate to the US legally or illegally and they have fought wars, built railroads, built tobacco empires that funded the Civil war for the Confederacy, worked in meat packing plants, picked mushrooms, and the list goes on and on. For blacks, and Hispanics, we have one thing in common. We don't look white. Jewish Irish, German, ITALIAN and Slavic people migrated here in the late 1800 and early 20th century and worked their butts off but they were not always subject to the same discrimination. They could look WASP so if they needed to blend they could.

    Now the issue has come to the forefront again. What do we do with the immigrants? We call them Aliens. The last time I check no one invited Columbus Amerigo or John Smith and his crew. But they came and took over. SO the country was started by ALIENS.

    When slavery ended America said, thank you for your work now go live as we do without education or any dependence on the government. hah I AM RAMBLING. Now we are trying to do the same thing to the Hispanics.

    The point is the true fear of American is that the population of Hispanics is growing at such a rate that by 2020 they will be the majority. Bush promised them these programs so they could stay and work. Then after their "cousins" elected him (you have to know he took the majority of the Hispanic vote) a big article appeared on CNN (IMMIGRATION PROBLEM)

    All of you who say we need to tighten our borders because of terrorism know damn well that the CANADIAN BORDER poses more of a threat.


    We need to grant citizenship to all of the people that have made it in thus far. Then I can see a reason to tighten the borders. All those employers who pay them little to nothing for work should be fined. There is a better way to do this I am sure. The current protests showed me on thing. America is still a very racist place.

    People were made because these people were flying their native flags. I wouldn't fly the flag of a country that accepts my labor but not me as a citizen. I am black and I still don't.

    They too wear the mask - Paul Lawrence Dunbar.

     
  • At April 14, 2006 9:44 AM, Blogger Jinxy said…

    What an unintentionally patronizing post.

    Deport all of them.

     
  • At April 14, 2006 1:24 PM, Blogger Carrie Broadshoulders said…

    Thanks for the history lesson anonymous but the idea that because everyone here is descended from someone who came here from elsewhere means we should let everyone who wants to come here come here now is just not only remedial but plain ignorant. We all know that the white folks came on boats and killed the Indians. But you know, the Indians came here from somewhere else as well. It's just a stupid argument. Stupid. Plain. Stupid.

    And to not want everyone on earth pouring into the United States isn't racist. It's common sense. You and everyone who uses that argument use it because you can't make a real argument as to why allowing illegal ALIENS to come here and work freely is a good idea. And there are arguments for why its a good thing. But racism? Gimme a break. I will admit there are plenty of people who don't want the Mexicans here b/c they are Mexican, but that doesn't mean the argument to keep them out is entirely racist.

    I'm sorry, but I don't accept the idea that I'm racist for being concerned about how we handle illegal workers in this country. And I don't need a history lesson. However you might since Irish and Italian people who came here were in fact discriminated against, however "white" they may have looked.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home

 
free webpage counters